Philippines abandons 2026 South China Sea code goal as China–ASEAN talks stall
The Philippines had meant to complete a South China Sea code of conduct with China during its 2026 ASEAN presidency, but at the mid-November summit in Manila it dropped that timetable. Foreign Secretary Theresa Lazaro said about 80% of the text was already negotiated; the remaining disputes—especially whether the code would be legally binding and how far it would apply geographically—were still unresolved.
The sea is a major shipping lane, a rich fishing ground, and a possible source of oil and gas, as well as a theater of strategic rivalry. China’s Nine-Dash Line overlaps claims by the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia and Brunei. A code of conduct is meant to set rules and stop incidents at sea from escalating. Andreas Ufen of the German Institute of Global and Area Studies (GIGA) argued that China has little incentive to accept a legally binding deal while it can already pursue its interests without one. Felix Heiduk of the German Institute for International and Security Affairs (SWP) noted that China and ASEAN have been negotiating for 12 years without major progress, and that some ASEAN states also hesitate because a binding treaty would have to be ratified at home. A non-binding text would amount mainly to a voluntary statement of intent.
Geographic coverage is equally contested: Vietnam wants the Paracel Islands (Xisha in China, Hoang-Sa in Vietnam) included; Beijing rejects that. What counts as an “incident”—coast-guard water cannon, blockades of supply ships, or only military force—is also unsettled, which will decide how much the rules actually constrain. Ufen sees Beijing as content to keep the dispute simmering without tying its own hands. ASEAN’s 11 members are divided: the Philippines and Vietnam are the most vocal against China; Malaysia and Indonesia are more cautious; Cambodia and Laos have close economic ties with Beijing and no South China Sea claims. Decisions require consensus, so any member can block a common position.
Continue in the app — vote & join in ➔